International News Opinion

Lessons From the U.S. Civil War Show Why Ukraine Can’t Win

 

During the early years of America’s Civil War, President Abraham Lincoln sought a limited conflict against people he still regarded as fellow countrymen and with whom he sought reconciliation. Only after three years of stalemate did he turn to “Unconditional Surrender Grant,” who in turn unleashed General William Tecumseh Sherman to “make Georgia howl” and help bring the war to its decisively violent conclusion.

Russian President Vladimir Putin waited only six months before switching from a special military operation to full scale war against Ukraine. Putin’s initial assault was limited to barely 150,000 troops. He expected a quick victory followed by negotiations on his principal concerns: Russian control of Crimea, Ukrainian neutrality, and autonomy for the Russian population in the Donbas, but he was wrong. Putin had not counted on Ukraine’s stiff resistance or the West’s massive military and economic intervention. Faced with a new situation, Putin changed his strategy. Now he is about to unleash his own General Sherman and make Ukraine howl.

Last month Putin gave General Sergey Surovikin overall command of Russia’s war in the Ukraine. Surovikin comes from the technologically sophisticated Aerospace Forces, but has fought on the ground in Afghanistan, Chechnya, and Syria where he is credited with saving the Assad regime. Surovikin has stated publicly that there will be no half measures in Ukraine. Instead, he has begun to methodically destroy Ukraine’s infrastructure with precision missile attacks.

Armies need railroads and while Sherman systematically tore up the tracks leading to Atlanta, Surovikin is destroying the electricity grid which powers Ukrainian railroads. This has left Ukrainian cities cold and dark, but Surovikin seems to agree with Sherman that “war is cruelty, and you cannot refine it.”

Russia has now put its economy on a war footing, called up the reserves, and assembled hundreds of thousands of troops, including both conscripts and volunteers. This army is equipped with Russia’s most sophisticated weapons, and contrary to much Western reporting, is far from demoralized. Ukraine on the other hand has exhausted its armories and is totally dependent on Western military support to continue the war. As Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff General Mark Milley noted last week, Ukraine has done about all it can.

READ MORE

Once Ukraine’s rich black soil has firmly frozen, a massive Russian onslaught will commence. In fact, it has already begun at the important transportation hub of Bakhmut, which has become something of a Ukrainian Verdun. We expect Bakhmut to fall and predict that without much more Western support, Russia will recapture Kharkov, Kherson, and the remainder of the Donbas by next summer.

As the West did in Vietnam, Afghanistan, and Iraq, we are stumbling into another optional, open-ended military commitment. Ukrainian troops are being trained in Europe. Western defense contractors are already maintaining Ukrainian military equipment and operating the HIMAR missile systems. Active-duty American military personnel are now in Ukraine to monitor weapons deliveries. As the Russian offensive gains momentum, we expect loud voices to call for sending ever-more advanced weapons and eventually NATO boots on the ground to defend Ukraine. These voices should be unambiguously rejected for many reasons. Here are a few.

Generations of Western leaders worked successfully to avoid direct military conflict with the Soviet Union. They recognized that, unlike Moscow, the West has very little strategic interest in who controls Donetsk. They were certainly unwilling to risk a nuclear war for Kharkiv. Ukraine is not a member of NATO, and the alliance has no obligation to defend it. Nor has Putin threatened any NATO member, but he has made clear that any foreign troops entering Ukraine will be treated as enemy combatants. Sending NATO troops into the Ukraine would thus turn our proxy war with Russia into a real war with the world’s largest nuclear power.

Some have presented this conflict as a morality play, between good and evil, but the reality is more complex. Ukraine is no flourishing democracy. It is an impoverished, corrupt, one-party state with extensive censorship, where opposition newspapers and political parties have been shut down. Before the war, far right Ukrainian nationalist groups like the Azov Brigade were soundly condemned by the U.S. Congress. Kiev’s determined campaign against the Russian language is analogous to the Canadian government trying to ban French in Quebec. Ukrainian shells have killed hundreds of civilians in the Donbas and there are emerging reports of Ukrainian war crimes. The truly moral course of action would be to end this war with negotiations rather than prolong the suffering the Ukrainian people in a conflict they are unlikely to win without risking American lives.

And then there is always the unexpected turn of events where tensions in one region compound and spill over into another. There is a growing possibility of Iran launching a preemptive military strike on Israel. The revolutionary regime in Iran is facing an increasingly serious popular revolt. A new government in Israel is determined to prevent Iran from acquiring nuclear weapons. The JCPOA is dying and with it any hope of sanctions relief for Iran’s failing economy. A war would unite Iran’s population in a patriotic struggle, damage Israel’s ability to strike Iran, and pressure the West to negotiate an end to sanctions.

There is little doubt that the United States would be drawn into any conflict between Israel and Iran. What worries us is that Iran has been supplying Russia with weapons for the war in Ukraine and Moscow might feel obliged to come to the aid of its allies in Tehran. That sort of domino effect is precisely what started the First World War. Who expected that the assassination of an Austrian grand duke by a Serbian anarchist in Bosnia would lead to thousands of Americans dying in France? We do not need a replay.

Perhaps we are wrong. Perhaps there will not be a Russian winter offensive or perhaps the Ukrainian armed forces will be able to stop it. However, if we are correct and February finds General Surovikin at the gates of Kiev, we need to have soberly considered and honestly debated as a nation and an alliance the extent of our commitment to Ukraine and what risks we are willing accept to our own security.

 

Note

David H. Rundell is a former chief of mission at the American Embassy in Saudi Arabia and the author of Vision or Mirage, Saudi Arabia at the Crossroads.

Ambassador Michael Gfoeller is a former Political Advisor to the U.S. Central Command. He served for 15 years in Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

You may also like

Business

Fintrak Software Presents Webinar on Navigating International Financial Reporting Standards in the African Digital Banking Space

post-image

 

 

In tandem with the widespread adoption of digital banking and virtual solutions in the African financial sector, Fintrak Software, a leading financial technology (fintech) software developer based in Lagos, Nigeria, is set to host a groundbreaking webinar titled “Managing Financial Reporting: Navigating Global Accounting Standards and Compliance” this December

The webinar aims to shed light on the imperative for financial institutions, especially banks, in Africa to align with the International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS). IFRS, established by the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB), serves as the global benchmark for transparent and comparable financial reporting across borders.

Fintrak Software has emerged as a pivotal player in this space, offering one of the most internationally recognized software solutions for banks, mortgage houses, and other financial entities. Their IFRS reporting software minimizes human error, ensuring compliance with the stringent standards set by IFRS.

Bimbo Abioye, the Group…

Read More
Business Culture

Imo State Broadcasting Corporation Welcomes New Director General, Ify Onyegbule

post-image

 

Imo State, November 28, 2022 – In a surprise announcement today, His Excellency, Senator Hope Uzodimma, the Governor of Imo State, appointed Ms. Ify Onyegbule as the new Director General of the Imo Broadcasting Corporation. The appointment marks a significant moment in Ms. Onyegbule’s career, catching her off guard as she diligently attended to her responsibilities at another radio station.

Reflecting on the unexpected turn of events, Ms. Onyegbule expressed her astonishment and gratitude for the new opportunity. Following the announcement, social media platforms buzzed with excitement, signaling the magnitude of her new role and increased responsibilities.

Having previously worked in both the civil service and private sector, Ms. Onyegbule acknowledged the transition as a time of unlearning and relearning. Managing a larger team and navigating the complexities of human resources in a public service setting presented a unique set of challenges and learning opportunities.

Over the past year, Ms. Onyegbule has…

Read More
Business Culture Events International Investments Leisure Tourism Travels

Radisson Hotel Group, in partnership with Edo State Government (EDSG), further expands its portfolio in Nigeria with its debut in Benin City, Edo State

post-image

Radisson Hotel Group (www.RadissonHotels.com), in partnership with the Edo State Government, is proud to announce its progressed expansion in Nigeria with the signing of Radisson Hotel Benin City. The 169-room hotel, scheduled to open within the next 12 months is the Group’s 12th hotel in Nigeria and officially marks their debut in Benin City.

 

The hotel’s array of Scandinavian inspired accommodation will range from contemporary standard rooms to expansive executive suites, including a presidential suite. Creating a social hub for delectable cuisine, the hotel’s gastronomic offering will include a lobby bar and café, an all-day dining restaurant as well as a pool bar and grill. To provide a harmonious stay, guests can also unwind in the hotel’s gym and spa.

 

With our ongoing commitment to expand in Nigeria, a key market in Africa for our scaled growth and Sub-Saharan Africa’s largest economy, the debut in Benin…

Read More
Business

Tata International expands operations in Nigeria at Lagos Free Zone

post-image

Tata International is set to expand operations in Nigeria through a strategic partnership with the Lagos Free Zone (LFZ) (https://LagosFreeZone.com). The agreement was signed in the presence of Anand Sen, Managing Director of Tata International Limited, by Managing Director of Tata Africa Holdings Pty Ltd, Len Brand. This marks a significant milestone in the company’s commitment to the region.

 

With a rich legacy spanning over four decades, Tata International is a key contributor to the economic landscape of the African continent. In 2006, Tata International established operations in Nigeria and since then has made a significant contribution in the country, upholding the core values of Tata’s business ethics and commitment to corporate social responsibility.

“As a brand synonymous with quality products and ethical business operations in Africa, Tata International is excited to join the Lagos Free Zone. This strategic move reflects our commitment to fuelling growth in…

Read More
Business Culture News

MIRACLE Izuchukwu Emerges as America’s Youngest Licensed Black Female Commercial Pilot

post-image

 

In a remarkable achievement, 24-year-old Nigerian sensation MIRACLE Izuchukwu has officially become America’s youngest licensed black female commercial pilot. Her inspiring journey took off as she transitioned from an airport customer service representative to a distinguished flight attendant, eventually soaring to new heights as a certified pilot.

Embodying the spirit of determination and passion, Izuchukwu expresses, “Flying is freedom. It’s a lifetime opportunity. I finally found a career that I love. Growing up, I had no idea what I wanted to do. I would watch a lot of TED Talks, thinking about a career I would love. Becoming a pilot is a fulfillment. I can do this job all day.”

Izuchukwu’s journey serves as an inspiration for aspiring aviators, particularly young girls. Her mission extends beyond her personal achievements, as she aims to encourage and guide the next generation of black girls aspiring to become pilots. “I want young girls to…

Read More
Business

Admirals introduces proprietary Trading & Investing platform

post-image

 

 

Poised for new market growth with the introduction of a simplified retail trading & investing platform 

 

Global fintech company Admirals has announced the launch of its own, custom-developed proprietary trading and investing platform to supplement its existing suite of platforms and solutions.

 

The development of this native platform supports the Group’s strategic expansion into the beginner trading and investing market. At the same time the addition of this platform offers a fresh alternative and streamlined experience to Admirals’ client-base.

 

With simplicity as the key differentiator, the new platform features a user-friendly design and intuitive interface that provides instant and easy access to Admirals’ vast selection of instruments and tools.

 

Being a web-based platform, the Admirals platform does not require clients to download or install any software. After completing the registration process, users can immediately start their trading and investing journey. Users can trade and invest on the…

Read More
Business Fintech Trends

ArcaPay Showcases Innovative Financial Technology Solutions at Zenith Bank’s Tech Fair 2023

post-image

ArcaPay, a pioneering indigenous financial technology (fintech) firm, took center stage at the prestigious Zenith Bank Tech Fair 2023, a gathering of the foremost tech players in Nigeria’s thriving tech ecosystem.

ArcaPay, recognized for its groundbreaking strides in Agency Banking, Switching Network, and payment gateway solutions, seized the opportunity to unveil its cutting-edge financial technology products on a global platform.

Nifemi Sofowora, Brand and Marketing Manager, conveyed the company’s mission at the event, stating, “We are here to showcase our products, foster relationships, and drive businesses. Our presence underscores our commitment to unveiling world-class solutions. We’re delighted to participate in this exhibition, showcasing our collaborative efforts with Zenith Bank.”

Highlighting the distinctive offerings at ArcaPay’s exhibition stand, Nifemi emphasized, “Our focus extends beyond financial solutions. We’re proud to present our unparalleled Agency Banking solutions, a one-of-a-kind innovation in Nigeria. This…

Read More
Business Economy

NITDA Director-General Stresses Urgency for Financial Institutions to Embrace AI and Data Analytics for Digital Payment Enhancement

post-image

The Director-General of the National Information Technology Development Agency (NITDA), Kashifu Inuwa Abdullahi, underscored the imperative for Nigerian Financial Institutions to adopt cutting-edge technologies such as Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Data Analytics to elevate digital payment systems.

This pivotal declaration took center stage at the Central Bank of Nigeria’s 2023 Payments System Management Department Retreat, where Inuwa accentuated the vital role of collaboration between NITDA, the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN), and other tech stakeholders for fostering exponential growth in the financial sector.

Represented by Engr Ya’u Garba, the National Director of the National Centre for Artificial Intelligence and Robotics (NCAIR), Inuwa acknowledged the substantial contribution of Financial Technology (FinTech) in propelling Nigeria’s recent industry performance. He specifically highlighted the positive impact of FinTech in Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) sectors, attributing this success to the effective application of developmental regulations and enabling policies.

The Director-General urged…

Read More