ECOWAS Court Dismisses SERAP’s Case Prosecuted By Falana Against FG

The Community Court of Justice of the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS) has dismissed six year application (ECW/CCJ/JUD/08/21) filed by the registered trustees of the Socio-Economic Rights and Accountability Project (SERAP) against the Federal Government.

In a judgment which was delivered on 26th April, 2021 the Court which was presided over by Hon. Justice Edward Amoaka ASANTE comprising two other members including Hon. Justice Gberi-Be OUTATTARA and Hon. Justice Januaria T. Silva Moreira COSTA declared the application inadmissible.

SERAP through its solicitors; Olufunmilola Falana (Mrs) Esq, Olusola Egbeyinka, Esq of Falana and Falana Chambers had on 4th April, 2016 filed an application at the ECOWAS against “violation of human rights of Nigerians and other individuals”.

Such rights according to the applicants included the rights to life, to security of the human persons, to the respect of the dignity inherent in a human being and right of property, guaranteed by Articles 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 14 of the African Charter, Articles 1, 2, 3, 7, 8 and 17 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Articles 2 and 6(1) of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.

The Federal Government solicitors; T.A Gazali,SAN and Adedayo Ogundele, Esq all of the Office of the Attorney General of the Federation, Federal Ministry of Justice, Abuja advanced responses ranging from:

(a) Denying committing any violation against some groups,

(b) Settlement of compensation, and

(C) Contention that most of the issues were either settled, or at the appeal courts for further interpretation and final resolution.

The Court further maintained that even where jurisdiction of Court is established, according to Article 10(d) of the Supplementary Protocol of the Court as amended, an application whose subject matter concerns human rights violation shall only be admissible when three criteria are met: the Applicant’s status as “victims” must be established, the non-anonymity of the application and the absence of litis pendence before another international Court or Tribunal.

According to the judgment:
“The Applicant having purportedly initiated the instant action on behalf of a community or group which lacks proper identification, Applicant’s locus standing in the matter cannot be sustained to admit the case for determination.

“Consequently, the action cannot be admitted under such a fatal capacity of the Applicant and same is dismissed in its entirety”.

“It must be further observed that the Applicant NGO has not been directly affected by the alleged violations, therefore it does not fulfill the requirement of being a victim on its own right”.

The Court judgment further stated that “the only ground to admit the case is on proof of the action being action popularis. However, the principles of public interest litigation and action popularis appear non-applicable to this case since the rights complained of, such as the right to life, to property, etc which primarily belongs to the victims and may only be claimed by them or their next-of-kins where necessary, have not been succinctly linked to the general public interest contemplated in the context of an action popularis.

“In the instant case, all the communities or groups on whose behalf the action is purportedly initiated to vindicate any alleged violations of their rights have themselves already taken various legal steps to remedy any wrongs if any.

The applicant case fails to clearly establish any community or groups whose public interest is allegedly breached and needs vindication as claimed,” the Court declared.

Responding to the development, the Attorney General of the Federation and Minister of Justice, Abubakar Malami described the judgment as a clear vindication of the Federal Government’s efforts towards respecting human rights and international conventions.

In a statement issued by Dr. Umar Jibrilu Gwandu, Special Assistant on Media and Public Relations in the office of the HAGF, Malami said the judgment has saved Nigeria from payment of billions of Nigeria’s naira for bogus claims.

Malami renewed the commitment of the Office of the Attorney General of the Federation and that of the Federal Government to protecting the rights of citizens in all ramifications as well as protecting the public interest in the discharge of constitutionally recognized mandate.

Modupe Ogundoro

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

You may also like

Business Fashion



Fenty Beauty and Fenty Skin will stage the biggest synchronized beauty launch across 8 countries on the African continent, with Nigeria being one of them, on Friday May 27th, 2022.

To commemorate this momentous occasion, the brand hosted the official launch party for celebrities, influencers, retail partners and media alike, dubbed “Fenty Club” at WBar in Lagos where over 200 attendees discovered the Fenty Beauty and Fenty Skin product offering and were treated to a special performance by Lojay and danced to the sounds of DJ Neptune. Of the notable attendees were Annie Idibia, Iyabo Ojo, Mariam Timmer, Adunni Ade, Linda Ejiofor, Zainab Balogun-Nwachukwu, Dimma Umeh, Mercy Eke, Cynthia Nwadiora, Tania Omotayo, Gbemi Olateru Olagbegi, Erica Nlewedim, Toyosi Etim Effiong amongst other notable figures.

Rihanna created both Fenty Beauty and Fenty Skin with a global vision in mind to…

Read More
Business Technology Trends

Bringing Efficiency to Credit Risk Management process using FinTrak Credit 360 Software


Fintrak Software Limited, Nigeria’s foremost indigenous financial technology (Fintech) solution provider with physical presence in some African countries recently brought the banking and financial industry stakeholders together to update them on their robust Credit Risk Management solution known as FinTrak Credit Risk 360. The industry experts applauded the software as a robust indigenous solution for banks in Africa.

Speaking during the presentation, the Group Managing Director, Bimbo Abioye stated that “FinTrak software delivers customized state of the art business transformation solutions that can intelligently combine efficiency with critical information needed for management decision-making process. FinTrak Credit 360 software has been able to improve user banks overall operational efficiency by over forty percent through automated strategic and digitized policy controls”

In order to limit human error to the barest minimum, Credit 360 solution comes with artificial…

Read More

Oyo Diocese Gets Microfinance Bank Approval


The joy of the people of the Catholic Diocese of Oyo (, especially those of Iwajowa Local Government and the entire Oke Ogun area, which population is roughly 1.5 Million knew no bounds with the recent news of approval of the license in principle for the Ave Maria Microfinance Bank (Proposed), being promoted by the diocese. The approval, coming coincidentally during the pastoral visit of the bishop Most Reverend Emmanuel Adetoyese Badejo to the Oke Ogun area is directly from the Central Bank of Nigeria. 

The effort of the diocese, which is situated in the Yoruba South West, marshalled by the diocesan coordinator of the Justice, Development and Peace Movement, (JDPM) Rev Fr. Gabriel Adeleke, is to address the peoples need for financial inclusion which is today widely considered a right of all citizens to social inclusion, to better quality…

Read More



We are aware of the latest statement from the so-called “Northern Elders Forum”.
We wish to reassure Nigerians that it remains their democratically elected leadership which takes the decisions that steer our nation – and no one else.

No self-appointed and unelected group can take this right from Nigerians – no matter how much coverage they might enjoy in the media. Nigerians listen to elected leaders, not opinionated tin-gods who have no traction with any responsible group.

It is a delusional arrogance that would lead such a group to publicly state terms and conditions for the existence of our nation.

Who gave them the right to ask for the exclusion, or expulsion of any one, group or section of the country from the Federal Republic of Nigeria?

The Nigerian government does not…

Read More



Anambra State and the South Eastern part of the country has lately been immersed in some level of insecurity. It has been alleged that it is the Unknown GunMen , a group that people have said that are allegedly agitating for a state of Biafra, but the only recognised group at it is  known today is the Independent People of Biafra (IPOB) has come out to distance themselves from the group causing troubles and killing in the Eastern part of the country. 

On this note, the newly sworn in Governor of Anambra state, Charles Soludo recently visited the leader of IPOB in the detention in Abuja where he is awaiting trials on several count charges ranging from treason to others. Soludo’s visit has shown that he is giving an olive branch and also implies that he has nothing against the…

Read More
Business Health

Duchess Hospital introduces Affordable World-class Healthcare for Families.


In line with its mission to provide Nigerians with the fastest, most convenient and affordable access to the best medical expertise available anywhere in the world, The Duchess International Hospital, Ikeja GRA, Lagos has launched an Access to Affordable World-class Healthcare programmme. With as little as N5000 registration to get family card and seeing renowned consultants starting from N5000, the management of Duchess Hospital is making a bold statement that the purpose-built, state-of-the art 100-bed hospital is not only for the elites.

Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of the hospital, Dr. Adetokunbo Shitta-Bey, said the Access to Affordable World-class Healthcare programme was designed to “provide access to the hospital’s extensive range of high-quality services in emergency medicine and critical care, women’s health and paediatric care services, cardiovascular medicine, kidney dialysis, endoscopy, medical and surgical treatment interventions, dental treatments, eye care services and a wide variety…

Read More
Business News Technology Technology Trends

XClub Appoints Iddy Brown as Country Team Manager for Nigeria


XClub Nigeria has promoted and Appointed Iddy Brown to the position of Country Team Manager for Nigeria, effective from 26th April, 2022.

Iddy, who joined the company in April 2021, held the position of Business Development Manager (KOL Management), before his announcement as the new Country Team Manager for XClub App in Nigeria.

In his previous role, he led the onboarding and Management of Micro and Mid-tier Tech Influencers and Content Creators who majors on Creating Content reviews around Smartphones and tech innovations on the App.

He also spearheaded XTech Talk Show, an in-app tech show on XClub where the XClub tech influencers converge to dissect the latest innovations in the smartphone/tech industry, and other activities that have contributed immensely in retention of daily and monthly active users on the App.

Business Government



The Honourable Minister of Water Resources and the Chairman, Council of Ministers, Lake Chad Basin Commission (LCBC), Engr. Suleiman Adamu FNSE, FAEng. has stated that the time to reinvigorate and strengthen regional cooperation among Countries in the Lake Chad Basin for sustained peace, stability, and prosperity is now.

Engr. Adamu made this known at the First Annual International Forum on the development of Lake Chad region with the theme “Lake Chad Basin: Climate Change, Security, Resilience and Development Recovery” held on Monday, 11th April 2022 in Abuja.

He stressed that multiple threats facing Lake Chad region’s common heritage such as climate change impacts, volatile insecurity, endemic poverty, health pandemics, are not country-specific but are transboundary in nature.

The Chariman, LCBC, stated that the theme of the Meeting was apt as it focused on the…

Read More